Papaz Gerald Murray, Vatikan’ın Rupnik Davasını Sorguluyor: New York’ta yaşayan bu kanon hukuku uzmanı, Vatikan’ın Marko Rupnik aleyhine açtığı kanonik davadaki şeffaflık eksikliğini eleştiriyor. 25 Temmuz’da Raymond Arroyo ile yaptığı sohbette “Neden yargıçların kim olduğunu bilmiyoruz?” diye sordu. Murray ayrıca, Rupnik’e karşı “hangi suçlamaların yöneltildiğini” bilmediğimizi de vurguladı. Son olarak, delil sunan mağdurların bu sürece katılma hakkına sahip olması gerektiğini savundu. “Tüm bu durum korkunç bir sorun.”
Michael Haynes - Lawyer for Rupnik's alleged victims said the Vatican has made no cont...
Lawyer for Rupnik's alleged victims said the Vatican has made no contact “Why don’t we know who the judges are?” adds @GeraldMurray8 “The whole thing is a horrific problem & the Holy See has not lived up to expectations it gives when victims come forward” On @CatholicHerald Michael Haynes (@MLJHaynes) on X
The victims' lawyer talks:
- Lawyer criticizes secrecy: Laura Sgrò, who represents five women accusing former Jesuit Marko Rupnik of abuse, says the Vatican's doctrinal office has ignored her requests for information about the case.
- Victims excluded: She says the alleged victims have not been called to testify, and her request to participate as their legal representative received no response.
- Calls for basic transparency: Sgrò says she is not asking for a public trial, only enough information to protect the victims' rights, including access to witness testimony.
- Judges remain anonymous: The Vatican has confirmed judges were appointed, but their identities are secret. Sgrò argues this prevents scrutiny of possible conflicts of interest and undermines confidence in the process.
Victims ignored: Rupnik’s trial is yet another …
How dare they question his unholiness? Stealth vendetta will follow soon...
No I wasn't. Even though they are "walking on eggshells" around the false prophet Prevost, at least they are not observing omertà of Trad Inc anymore.
Who are you referring to? I do not dispute the sinful nature of the acts in question, provided they actually occurred. My grievance is specifically with the "Prayerful Posse." They criticize the Vatican in a way that leads conservative viewers to think, "The 'Prayerful Posse' is on the right track." In reality, however, the program serves merely to keep conservatives docile. Active resistance—such as that demonstrated by the Society of Saint Pius X through its episcopal consecrations—is repeatedly and vehemently rejected.
Was regt Ihr Euch auf, Herr Arroyo und Hochwürden Murray? Ihr bestreitet ja doch die Notlage von Can, 1323 CIC und seid gegen die FSSPX.
Der Konservativismus von "Prayerful Posse" geht ins Leere. Der konservative Zuschauer soll sich verstanden fühlen, aber letztlich lehnt Ihr Widerstand ab und kritisiert die Bischofsweihen der FSSPX.
Rev. Gerald Murray spochybňuje vatikánsky proces s Rupnikom: Kánonický právnik pôsobiaci v New Yorku kritizuje nedostatočnú transparentnosť vatikánskeho kánonického procesu proti Markovi Rupnikovi. „Prečo nevieme, kto sú sudcovia?“ spýtal sa v rozhovore s Raymondom Arroyom 25. júla. Rev. Murray tiež poukázal na to, že „nevieme, aké obvinenia“ sú proti Rupnikovi vznesené. Nakoniec argumentuje, že obete, ktoré poskytli dôkazy, by mali mať právo zúčastniť sa na konaní. „Celá táto záležitosť je strašný problém.“
Satanova cirkev, či skôr neviestka nemôže konať inak, lebo krytie sexuálnych predátorov má v DNA. Dokonca sa neštíti ani vrážd.
O reverendo Gerald Murray questiona o processo contra Rupnik no Vaticano: O especialista em direito canónico, sediado em Nova Iorque, critica a falta de transparência no processo canónico do Vaticano contra Marko Rupnik. «Porque é que não sabemos quem são os juízes?», questionou ele numa conversa com Raymond Arroyo, a 25 de julho. O reverendo Murray salientou ainda que «não sabemos quais são as acusações» que estão a ser feitas contra Rupnik. Por fim, defende que as vítimas que prestaram depoimentos deveriam ter o direito de participar no processo. «Tudo isto constitui um problema terrível.»
Ks. Gerald Murray kwestionuje proces Rupnika w Watykanie: ten nowojorski prawnik kanoniczny krytykuje brak przejrzystości w toczącym się w Watykanie procesie kanonicznym przeciwko Marko Rupnikowi. „Dlaczego nie wiemy, kim są sędziowie?” – zapytał w rozmowie z Raymondem Arroyo 25 lipca. Ks. Murray zwrócił również uwagę, że „nie wiemy, jakie zarzuty” postawiono Rupnikowi. Na koniec argumentuje, że ofiary, które przedstawiły dowody, powinny mieć prawo do udziału w postępowaniu. „Cała ta sprawa stanowi przerażający problem”.
Il reverendo Gerald Murray mette in discussione il processo contro Rupnik al Vaticano: il canonista con sede a New York critica la mancanza di trasparenza nel processo canonico avviato dal Vaticano contro Marko Rupnik. «Perché non sappiamo chi siano i giudici?», ha chiesto durante un colloquio con Raymond Arroyo il 25 luglio. Il reverendo Murray ha inoltre sottolineato che «non sappiamo quali siano le accuse» mosse contro Rupnik. Infine, sostiene che le vittime che hanno fornito prove dovrebbero avere il diritto di partecipare al processo. «L’intera vicenda rappresenta un problema terribile».
Gerald Murray atya kérdőjelezi meg a Vatikán Rupnik-perét: A New York-i székhelyű kánonjogász bírálja a Marko Rupnik ellen indított vatikáni kánonjogi eljárás átláthatóságának hiányát. „Miért nem tudjuk, kik a bírák?” – kérdezte július 25-én Raymond Arroyo-val folytatott beszélgetésük során. Murray atya arra is rámutatott, hogy „nem tudjuk, milyen vádak” merültek fel Rupnik ellen. Végül azt állítja, hogy a bizonyítékokat szolgáltató áldozatoknak joguknak kellene lennie ahhoz, hogy részt vegyenek az eljárásban. „Az egész ügy rettenetes probléma.”
El reverendo Gerald Murray cuestiona el proceso contra Rupnik en el Vaticano: Este especialista en derecho canónico, afincado en Nueva York, critica la falta de transparencia en el proceso canónico del Vaticano contra Marko Rupnik. «¿Por qué no sabemos quiénes son los jueces?», preguntó en una conversación con Raymond Arroyo el 25 de julio. El reverendo Murray también señaló que «no sabemos de qué se le acusa» a Rupnik. Por último, sostiene que las víctimas que aportaron pruebas deberían tener derecho a participar en el proceso. «Todo este asunto es un problema terrible».
Le révérend Gerald Murray remet en question le procès de Rupnik au Vatican: ce canoniste basé à New York critique le manque de transparence du procès canonique intenté par le Vatican contre Marko Rupnik. « Pourquoi ne savons-nous pas qui sont les juges ? », a-t-il demandé lors d’un entretien avec Raymond Arroyo le 25 juillet. Le révérend Murray a également souligné que « nous ne savons pas quelles accusations » sont portées contre M. Rupnik. Enfin, il fait valoir que les victimes qui ont apporté des preuves devraient avoir le droit de participer à la procédure. « Toute cette affaire est un problème effroyable. »
Les gigantesques et très saintes réformes de Vatican d'eux ne poussent notre hiérarchie à la mise à jour des vieilleries autoritaires dans l'état du Vatican ?
Comme c'est curieux.
Pfarrer Gerald Murray hinterfragt das Rupnik-Verfahren im Vatikan: Der in New York ansässige Kirchenrechtler kritisiert die mangelnde Transparenz im kirchenrechtlichen Verfahren des Vatikans gegen Marko Rupnik. „Warum wissen wir nicht, wer die Richter sind?“, fragte er am 25. Juli im Gespräch mit Raymond Arroyo. Pfarrer Murray wies zudem darauf hin, dass „wir nicht wissen, welche Vorwürfe“ gegen Rupnik erhoben werden. Schließlich argumentiert er, dass Opfer, die Beweismittel vorgelegt haben, das Recht haben sollten, an dem Verfahren teilzunehmen. „Die ganze Angelegenheit ist ein schreckliches Problem.“
Rev. Gerald Murray Questions Vatican's Rupnik Trial: The New York-based canon lawyer criticises the lack of transparency in the Vatican's canonical trial against Marko Rupnik. "Why don't we know who the judges are?" he asked talking to Raymond Arroyo on 25 July. Rev Murray also pointed out that "we don't know which charges" are being levelled against Rupnik. Finally, he argues that victims who provided evidence should have the right to participate in the process. "The whole thing is a horrific problem."